First CJKMI(Oct., 1999, Suzhou, China) Beijing: Xue Yuan Publishing house
1999. All right reservedProceedings of The
First China-Japan-Korea Joint Symposium on Medical Informatics(CJKMI’99),1999,177-181 HCSL: a Human-Computer Commonly Understandable and Communicatable Medical Language Han-Fei Bao computer network center Shanghai University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, China Abstract This article presented an exploratory program to format a kind of half-structured and half-natural medical language which would be understandable by both human and computer, and communicatable between them. The purpose of it is to develop a new type of medical knowledge base by which human and computer could “talk” more thoroughly. Some philosophic discussion, the classification and exemplification of the elements and relations of the language were given as Keywords
Medical Knowledge Integration; Artificial Medical Intelligence; Internet
1. Some Philosophic Thoughts
Medical knowledge system is an infinite system which covers all the relations in and between two
spaces, the space inside the body and the space outside the body.
Any individuals should, for the purpose of their living and health, know some basic medical
knowledge, whereas a doctor should, for the purpose of helping people with their living and health,
know all the knowledge in his or her field.
In this aspect, people are challenged by the features of medical knowledge and their relevant
• The hiddenness. The events or processes actually happen in the body are usually unobservable
• The indefiniteness. The multiple possibilities of inner processes of the body exist for the same
• The boundlessness. Namely, there are no definite boundaries between the knowledge scopes of
the specialty fields. They are connected each other.
• The inseparateness. The discovery of medical knowledge is needed to do by way of “social
division of labour”, but the nature and the application of medical knowledge are of
Perhaps because doctors are the noble kings in the medical kingdoms, little researches of medical
informatics in the past were aimed at the limitedness of the doctor’s memory and shortness of their
thought. The fact is that a good doctor spends most of his or her spare time in reading medical
books and journals. The knowledge scope in doctor’s memory is never large enough to do their
works as well as desired (a similar view point can see [3]). Doctors need always to “talk” with
books and journals to extend their knowledge area. Nevertheless, the doctors are isolated in the
narrow knowledge world by the invisible ignorance-wall and the area outside is still something
like unknown “stars of outer space” for them.
IREMB (Integratable Relationized Electronic Medical Book) has tried to develop a research
program of “linking engineering” between various medical knowledge elements, units (or
relations) and fields. It is considered that in the computer era the medical knowledge system
should be no longer traditionally pile-typed, but somewhat nervous-system-typed or
communication-system-typed. For this goal, a new kind of half-structured and half-natural
language which can be understood and processed by both human and computer is basically
necessary. We might call it human-computer shared language (HCSL).
Due to the different aims of problem observation, analysis and process in the various knowledge
fields, the degree of simplification, generalization and abstraction of the simplification,
generalization and abstraction of the knowledge are different. From lower degree to higher
degree, the knowledge might be divided into three levels: physical level,
systems-logic-mathematics-computer sciences level (SLMC level) and philosophy level. The
knowledge of physical level covers all the practical problems, being generalized according to its
physical methodology and expressed mainly by the natural language. That of SLMC level is
generalized depending on the formalized methods and expressed usually by the structured
language [1-2], such as various personal, medium, large data bases. It is difficult to use these
absolutely restricted and formatted languages to express the majority or whole of medical
knowledge. As for the knowledge of philosophy level, it is always generalized and abstracted on
In accordance with the three-level-division, our HCSL should be inserted into between SLMC
level and physical level, resulting in a four-level-knowledge-division:
The IREMB medical knowledge base structured by HCSL language consists of three parts over all
[4-16]. ①The element files which consist of the sets of encoded medical knowledge elements at
physical level. ②The relation files each of which is composed of a set of medical knowledge
units being formated by one of so called “knowledge driving verbs (KDVs)”. Now at the initial
stage (“one-person huge program” stage) of IREMB, only ten KDVs have been specified. They
are ten generalized verbs: (pan) creating (-CREAT-), (pan) increasing (-INCRS-), (pan) decreasing
(-DECRS-), (pan) containing (-CONTN-), (pan) passageway (-PASTO-), (pan) accompanying
(-COMPN-), (pan) transforming (-TRANS-), (pan) equating (-EQUAL-), (pan) ordering
(-PORDR-), (pan) irrelating (-PNULL-). In future, along side the development of IREMB , there
might be tens or hundreds of KDVs needed to be specified. ③A series of softwares of IREMB,
including editing system, maintaining systems, searching systems, automated logic-guided reading
functions and other artificial intelligent functions.
2. The Sorts of Medical Elements
Any medical objects, e. g., substances, concepts, movements, functions, processes etc. are
splittable, endlessly and infinitely. Therefore we mention “medical elements” always in relative
sense. In IREMB, a simple element contains only one element, whereas a complex element
contains two or more elements, linked with complex sign “-”.
The complex medical elements might be exampled by “glucokinase–synthesis”, “monilia
albicans-septicemia”, “expiratory center-excitability”, “fatty liver-cause”, “aspirintoxic or side
reaction”, “aspirin-careful use”, “therapy”, etc.
The medical elements might in HCSL be farther subdivided into the subelements so called
“meaning elements”, which are the concepts of high occurrence rate in medical knowledge, but
not the integral medical objects. The examples of “meaning” elements are “excitability”,
“activity”, “predilection site”, “susceptible population”, “predilection age”, “after meals”, “before
meals”, “excretion”, “therapy”, etc.
Based on their physical nature, the medical elements might be classified into following aspects:
substance, concept, structure, movement, time, place, state (behaviour, form, feature, attribute,
quantity, degree, parameter…), ability, domain, process (complex of state and time),
relation ’substance-substance relation, process-process relation), etc. They are exemplified in the
Concept: “first cause of death”, “contraindication”, “inversion”, … State: “hypothermia”,
“weakness”, “refraction change”, … Domain: “individual patient”, “patient with disease history
of more than 20 years”, “patient of attack age more than 20 years”, … Process:
“gluconeogenesis”, “fat decomposition”, “ketone bodies generation”, “protein synthesis”,
“absorption of Vit B12”, “intravenous injections, …Parameter: “secretion index of insulin”, “lipid
clearance rate”, “diameter of blood vessel”, “respiratory tract resistance”,… Quantity or Degree:
“large dose”, “excessive dose”, “number of B cell”, “slight abnormality”, … Place:
“HLA-control gene-site”, “in vivo”, … Time: absolute time (A. D. time), relative time (from
beginning of the events) [17], e.g. “after meals”, “before meals”, … Compounded sort:
self-compounded, reciprocal compounded, compounded of compounded element sorts.
On the basis of their operation attributes, the elements might be devided into following types. ①
The elements with KDV meaning component: e.g. “analgesia”, “antithermic function”,
“anti-inflammatory function”, “antirheumatic function”, … ② The elements might be
transformed into KDV, such as “indication”, “therapy”, “contraindication”, “noneatable foods”,
“less eatable foods”, … ③Editing elements: those strings with high occurrence rate in medical
3. The Sorts of Medical Relations
Medical relations, or knowledge units, are constructed in IREMB by three sets, i.e. subject
element set (SES), object element set (OES) and condition element set (CES), which are linked by
relation words KDVs and/or condition word (CWD): “UNDER PANCONDITION”. Thus they
have the same form “SES-KDV-OES -(-CWD- CES) ”. Again based on their physical meaning,
the medical relations could be roughly categorized and exemplified as followings.
3.1 Pan-excluding relations
The subject element set and object element set repel each other. e. g., “headache due to
hypertension”-“abstain from” -CONTN- “ergotamine”. “asthma”-“noneatable food”- CONTN-
“hairtail”, “yellow croaker”, “razor clam”, “shrimp”, “crab”, “ leaf mustard ” . “hypertension”-“less eatable food” - CONTN- “yolk”, “cream”, “pork liver”, “pig brain”.
“rifampin”-“abstain from”- CONTN- “paminosalicylic acid (PAS)”, “oral antihyperglycemic”,
“fregnant woman”, “alcoholism”, “hepatic insufficiency”. The elements “abstain from”,
“noneatable food”, “less eatable food” have the same or approximate operational attribute.
3.2 Pan-accompanying relations
They are not definite causalities, but coexistence relations. e. g. , “rheumatoid nodules”
–COMPN- “rheumatoid factor titer increased”. “V type hyperlipemia”-COMPN- “obesity”,
“hyperuricemia”, “diabetes”, “acute pancreatitis” “hepatomegaly”, “splenomegaly”, “chronic
active hepatitis (CAH )”-“complication” -CONTN- “nephritis”, “arthritis”, “angitis”,
“dermatomyositis”, “myocarditis”, “sicca syndrome”, “endocrine dysfunction”, “ulcerative
3.3 Pan-construction relations
They are whole-part relations. e. g. , “hemorrhoid”-“class” -CONTN- “internal hemorrhoid”,
“external hemorrhoid”, “mixed hemorrhoik”. “acute pancreatitis”- “ stage” -CONTN-
“edematous pancreatitis”, “necrotic pancreatitis”. “yolk”, “cream”, “brain”, “liver” -CONTN-
“cholesterol” –CWD- “content:”-“rich”. 3.4 Pan-creation relations
They are causalities, the “causes” preexist and keep unchanged, whereas the “results” are new
born. e. g. , “chronic alcoholism” –CREAT- “hepatocirrhosis”. “anger”, “mental stress” –CREAT- “spasm of gastric muscle”, “spasm of gastric microangium”. “uterine prostaglandin” –CREAT- “dysmenorrhea”. “liver” –CREAT- “coagulation factor II”, “coagulation factor VII”,
“coagulation factor IX”, “coagulation factor X”. “Vit B12”-“deficiency” –CREAT- “spinal cord
degeneration”, “intelligence going down”. “indolol”-“toxic and side effect” -CONTN-
“headache”, “tinnitus”, “sleepless”, “nausea”, “vomiting”, “diarrhea”. These relations can be
formatted in opposite direction as well. e. g. , “Raynaud’s disease”-“inducing factor” -CONTN-
“emotion excitement”, “coldness”. “Vit K 2”-“source” -CONTN- “synthesis by intestinal
bacterium”. “fatty liver”-“cause” -CONTN- “alcoholism”, “obesity”, “diabetes”. 3.5 Pan-equivalence relations
In these relations, the subject elements get or partly get the values, meanings or their equivalences.
e. g. , “secondary”-“dysmenorrhea”-“definition” –EQUAL- “dysmonorrhea due to other
gynecopathy”. “latent jaundice”-“icterus index” –EQUAL- “7-15(”. “serum”-“total
bilirubin”-“normal concentration” –EQUAL- “0.1-1.0mg/dl”.
“I type hyperlipoproteinemia” –EQUAL- “hyperchylomicronemia”. “Vit B12”-“physiologic
meaning” -CONTN- “take part in formation of pyrimidine and purine”, “coenzyme of DNA
synthesis”. “total cholesterol”-“decrease”-“clinical meaning” -CONTN- “acute hepatonecrosis”,
“hepatocirrhosis”, “hypothyroidism”, “severe malnutrition”, “severe anemia”. “Vit
B12”-“absorption site” –EQUAL- “end of ileum”. “Raynand’s disease”-“predilection sex” –EQUAL- “female”. 3.6 Pan-recognition relation
The relations represent the symptoms, features, appearances. etc. of the subject elements. e. g. ,
“urinary tract infection”-“symptom” -CONTN- “fever”, “chilly”, “aching pain in lumbar region”,
“frequent micturtion”, “urgency of micturition”, “pain of micturtion”, “pyuria”, “bacteruria”.
“bronchial asthma”-“forewarning” -CONTN- “nasal itch”, “sneezing”, “laryngeal itch”, “chest
distress”, “cough”. “acute pancreatitis”-“pathologic change” -CONTN- “pancreatic acinus
destruction”, “pancreatic duct rupture”. “chronic active hepatitis”-“laboratory examination”
-CONTN- “V factor decreased”, “VII factor decreased”, “white bood cell decreased”,
“thrombocyte decreased”, “IgG positive”, “lupus cell positive”, ……
3.7 Pan-transform relations
They are another kind of causality, the process is “subject elements preexist? Object elements new
born and subject elements died”. e. g. , “fatty liver” -TRANS- “hepatocirrhosis” –CWD- “long
term alcoholism”. “folic acid” -TRANS- “tetrahydrofolic acid” –CWD- “explanation:”-“in
vivo”-“folic acid reductase”-“dihydrofolate reductase”. “tetrahydrofolic acid”-“methyl”-TRANS- “N5-methyl tetrahydrofolic acid”. 3.8 Pan-inhibition relations
For example,“adrenosem salicylate” –DECRS- “capillary permeability”. “metronidazole” –DECRS- “trichomonas vaginalis”, “anaerobic bacteria”, “bacillus coli”, “bacillus proteus”,
“pneumobacillus”. “Vit B6” –DECRS- “cholesterol”. “cimetidine”-“indication” -CONTN-
“duodenal ulcer”, “acute hemorrhagic lesion of gastric mucosa”, “hirsutism”, “gastric ulcer”.
The followings are pan-inhibition relations in opposite direction.
“chronic bronchitis”-“suitable food” -CONTN- “bean products”, “green vegetable”, “carrot”,
“functional maldigestion”-“therapy” -CONTN- “metoclopramide”, “domperidone (motilium)”,
“cisapride (prepulside)”. “fatty liver”-“prevention” -CONTN- “high-protein diet”, “limit diet 3.9 Pan-promotion relations
For example, “cell decomposition” –INCRS- “potassium in urine”. “cold”, “eat raw or cold
food” –INCRS- “dysmenorrhea”. “insulin” –INCRS- “glucose”-“getting into cell”. 3.10 Pan-displaement relations
These relations represent the passageway by which the substances (or process) move from one site
to another site. e. g. , “liver”-“bile acid” –PASTO- “intestinal tract”-“bile acid”.
“glucose-6-phosphate” –PASTO- “phosphopentose pathway”, “glucuronic acid metabolism 3.11 Pan-order relations
These relations mean time-order, quantitative order, degree order, comparison, unequivalence, etc.
–PORDR- represents “the subject elements are “stronger than” (or “more than”, “ealier than”, …)
object elements”. e. g. , “after meals”-“LPL activity” –PORDR- “fasting”-“LPL-activity”. “left
atrial”-“depolarization”-“time-order” –EQUAL- “anterior wall of right atrium”, “interatrial fiber
linking anterior walls of left and right atriums”, “anterior wall of left atrium”, “left aurcle”,
3.12 Pan-mixed relations
The physical meanings of these relations are dependent on the operational components of object
elements. e. g. , “salbutamol”-“function” - CONTN- “dilate bronchus”. “ibuprofen
(brufen)”-“function” - CONTN- “anti-inflammation”, “analgisia”, “antitherm”, “antirheumatism”. 3.13 Pan-undefinite-or-negation relations
These relations are represented by undefinite elements such as “cause unknown” or negative
elements, e. g. “no symptom”. For example: “prostatic calculus”-“cause” - CONTN- “cause
unknown”. “prostatic calculus”-“symptom”- CONTN-“no symptom”. 3.14 Other relations
The relations beyond the above relations.
This is the broad outline of the primary HCSL of IREMB. It is believed that HCSL such
constructed could cover the most substantial part of the medical knowledge system and might be
operational by computer and, simultaneously, understandable by human. Based on HCSL,
powerful medical intelligent functions could be explored and developed. Any relations (or
knowledge units) in any medical fields could be reachable, connectable, ’some of them) deducible
and, to some extent, integratable. Some of operation functions have been developed in personal
computer [12-16]. The seaching functions have been running on the web sites of Internet:
202.121.32.10/bhf/tcmbke.htm (English) and 202.121.32.10/bhf/tcmbkc.htm (Chinese) (mainly
for Traditional Chinese Medicine, TCM), and www.sh.col.com.cn/bhf//bhf/ebao.htm (English) and
www.sh.col.com.cn/bhf/bhf/cbao.htm (Chinese) (mainly for West Medicine) [16]
4. Acknowledgement
The author would like to express his heartful thanks to Miss Ying Jie Bao for her secretarial work.
5. References
[1] Wu X.M.: The Pansystems View of the World. Beijing: Publishing House of China People
[2] Wu X.M.: Pansystems Philosophy and Its Encyclopedia-Connecting Application.Advances in
Systems Science and Applications (Inanguration Issue), 1995, pp198-203
[3] B. de Farie Leao: Synopsis: Knowledge Processing, Year Book of Medical Informatics, 1986,
[4] Bao H.F.: The Structure Characteristics of the New Research QMSOC and Its Relevant
Operators, J Tongji Med Univ, 1989, 9 (4), pp235-238
[5] Bao H.F.: The New Functions of Quantitatively Medicine Simulating and Operating by
Computer —New research QMSOC (III), 1990, J Tongji Med. Univ, 10 (1), pp52-56
[6] Bao H.F., Geng J.H. and Su Z.F.: Pansystems Methodology (PM) and a New Research on
Large-scale Integration of Biomedicine-An Introduction of QMSOC and Its Recent
Progresses , Acta of Jiansu Industrial College, Journal of Jiangsu Institute of Technology,
[7] Bao H.F.: Information Medicine and Its Primary Function of Exploitation of Medical
Resources, J Tongji Med Univ, 1991, 11 (1), pp59-64
[8] Liu S.C., Geng J.H.and Bao H.F: The Differentiation Model of Human-Embryo of
Computerized Multi-Field Integrated Instructing System-QMSOC and Computer-aided
Medicine Education (I), Special Issue of Application Research of Computer (in Chinese),
[9] Bao H.F.: Integratable Relationized Medical Electronic Book (IRMEB)-QMSOC and
Computer-aided Medicine Education (II), China High-Education Research (in Chinese), 1993,
[10] Bao H.F., Wang Y., and Ao Z.J.: Auto-reasoning Function of Simple Transmissible
Knowledge Chain of Integratable Relationized Medical Electronic Book (IRMEB)-QMSOC
and Computer-aided Medicine Education(III), Medicine Education, 1998, No.8, pp17-23
[11] Bao H.F., Wang Y., and Liu S.C.: The Background, Structure, Program-Development and
Functions of Integratable Relationized Medical Electronic Book (IRMEB)-QMSOC and
Computer-aided Medicine Education (IV), Special Issue of Application Research of
Computer (in Chinese), 1995, No.2, pp34-40
[12] Bao H.F., Yang L., and Dai Y.: The Present Progresses of the Integration Engineering of
Medical Knowledge Developed under the Inflneuce of Pansystems Theory-QMSOC and
Computer-aided Medicine Education (V), China High-Education Research (in Chinese),
[13] Bao H.F., Wang Z.F.: The Exploration of the Method to Counter Madical Knowledge
Explosion-QMSOC and Computer-aided Medicine Education (VI), China High-Education
Research (in Chinese), 1997, vol.11, No.2, pp13-19
[14] Bao H.F., Ni X.W., Lou S.: Integratable Relationized Medical Electronic Book (IRMEB)—
An Exploration of an New Type of Intellegent Knowledge Medium under the Influence of
Pansystems Theory. Advances in Systems Science and Applications (Inauguration Issue)
[15] Bao H.F: The Integrating Engineering of Medical Knowledge by Computer under the
Influence of Pansystems Theory, General Systems Studies and Applications, 1997,
[16] Bao H.F., Wang Z. F., Ji H. L.: The Intelligent Medical Book IREMB on Internet Developed
under the Influence of Pansystems Theory. The Third Workshop of the International
Institute for General Systems Stidies (IIGSS): Systems Sciences and Its Application.
[17] J. H. van Bemmel, M. A. Musen: Handbook of Medical Informatics, Bohn Stafleu Van
Pharma in brief - Canada Federal Court upholds validity of patent for escitalopram (CIPRALEX®) Escitalopram ((+)-Citalopram) (CIPRALEX®) Nature of case: Impeachment Action and Counterclaim for Infringement Successful party: Date of decision: Apotex Inc. (“Apotex”) brought an action for impeachment seeking a declaration that Lundbeck’s Canadian Patent No. 1,33
Jeffrey M. Spivak MD Director, NYU Hospital for Joint Diseases Spine Center Following lumbar disc surgery, patients typically return home the evening of surgery or after an overnight stay if the surgery is performed later in the day. Generally the discharge time has been discussed between yourself and Dr. Spivak prior to surgery, but this can be changed based on how you feel shortly after the